Discussion in 'Clothing & Footwear' started by Lancslad, Feb 18, 2019.
I’m selling a nearly new Hymir smock on here .. very breathable
Was impressed by my GF's Precip. She ordered a bright yellow XS one. It was snug so she returned it for a S in navy blue - less happy about the colour but is better for layering.
Got me thinking about pit zips (I know, I need to get out more)... My Helium II is nice but has no pit zips. Needs reproof ing too... Starting to think a cheaper fully waterproof rain jacket with pit zips is the way to go.
I'd really like to see some real world comparative tests of waterproof jackets. A few years ago Ride (the motorcycle) magazine got a few mugs to put on rain jackets and had some firemen attempt to drench them. I bought the best buy from that test made by Held and it has never let me down despite riding for 6 hours in torrential rain on the way back from Scotland. It doesn't breath and is too heavy for backpacking otherwise I'd probably use it.
I've found that most hiking rain jackets I've owned work well for a couple of hours of heavy continuous rain and then something, usually the zip, lets them down and you get wet. What I really want is one that will be good for 6 hours of heavy continuous rain so you can get a decent days hike in without feeling miserable.
It would be good if members could post their experiences of rain wear in long heavy rain days. Or at least if anyone has found one that works I'd love to hear.
Columbia Outdry: Is this the right one? Only £90 on SportPursuit.
Wont let me see. It should be called as per my post (COEF) on the 23rd April if that is the one you are referring to.
No it looks different.
It's the same principle but a heavier jacket IIRC.
Looks like the Eco has 'normal' zippers & rain flaps whereas the Featherweight uses water resistant zippers & pockets are cut differently.
370 gr in size L according to one review, 480 in size XL according to another and the Columbia site says 280 in size M.
I was torn between the Hellium and the Arcteryx zeta Sl but ended up getting a Montbell versalite instead in a sale , still tempted to get the Arcteryx as well
Cant say how good the versalite is, worn it a few times but not in proper rain, I cant say I'm massively confident of it in good old Scottish mountain rain as it's that light and thin, hopefully it surprises me. My XL is 196g has good pockets and velcro cuffs (the main reasons I choose it over the hellium) and pit zips (that I could live without tbh, not something I utilise very often). Pleasantly surprised to find I can also get it on top of my down layers, as I find montbell in general to be quite fitted.
200g difference between M and XL - I'm suspicious.
By same principle, I meant the Ex Outcry waterproofing.
I recon I might just buy a Marmot Precip from here for £54, delivered. I like storm flap, quite light weight, cheap.
Indeed. The XL weight is from Section Hiker, I would expect him to have weighed it...
Does this precip LITE jacket have pitzips? Not mentioned in description.
Yep. Because it is. At the time and perhaps still, it was the lightest non DWR required, backpack waranteed (armourised outer surface) rain jacket. My L is 210 gms. Like it very much. Front vents work a charm.
No pit zips unfortunately.
Wet on the outside.
Wet on the inside
Just how bad ? I did wonder about buying one ……
I was damp before, then working hard with 500m climb, pouring rain, and 13°C....
So hardly ideal.
Little would have coped I suspect.
I’ve been impressed with mine
I read this and asked Chris Townsend for recommendations and bought the smock version because I saw one very cheap on Sportsshoes. https://www.tgomagazine.co.uk/review/review-omm-aether-jacket/
He was trying it on the TGO; I saw him in Braemar... He'd have needed it that evening as it peed down.
I stayed in a B&B
Nice colour never seen the lime in the wild. The only times I felt unusually damp on the inside were in these exact conditions. Was already a bit damp but made the mistake of having too much clothing on. I should have stripped off a bit. When I managed to be lightly layered (LS capilene baselayer only) worked very well for me. Were you wearing much under @edh ?
Just noticed you have fhe front vents shut -had you tried them open and shut them due to rain getting in? I've managed to keep them open in some heavy rain. They are fhe key I reckon.
Hood is poor bit I’ve put to press stoods either side of hood then one on the top that clips to top of my baseball hat
A short sleeve Arc Motus. Arc shorts. That's it, I run hot when walking. I had a cuben rainskirt on some of the time.
Agree re. the vents; on this occasion it was not an option though.
It was the wettest weather I've been in for a few years.
Anyway.... I'm here now
Separate names with a comma.